When was the battle for marjah

It's really insulting to just fake someone's music so much that it almost sounds identical because the artist wouldn't authorize its use, but considering how much GY! BE despises the military industrial complex, it's just that much more insulting. Either Mr. Phillips was explicitly asked to make a track that sounded exactly like the opening for East Hastings key, tone, character, mood, guitar sound, bass line, and melody , or whoever signed off on the music was blissfully ignorant that it was a shameless rip-off.

Either way, Andrew Phillips is the one who made the music, and whether he's just an unoriginal hack, or he just did what needed to be done to get a paycheck, he really should be ashamed of himself. Other than that, it's a pretty interesting documentary.

Details Edit. Release date February 17, United States. United States. HBO Documentary Films. Technical specs Edit. Runtime 1 hour 28 minutes. Related news. Dec 14 SoundOnSight. Dec 5 SoundOnSight. Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content. Top Gap. What is the English language plot outline for The Battle for Marjah ? See more gaps Learn more about contributing. Afghan farmers made a lot more money with opium compared to other crops, and local drug cartels were unwilling to lose their principal source of income.

I remember hearing that one of the residents asked an interpreter if the Marines in Marjah were part of the government. Ultimately, while incredible risks were endured, and sacrifices made by Marines and coalition forces, the battle for Marjah was set up for failure, at least in the long term.

Looking back at it, five years later, the whole thing seems more absurd than triumphant. With its two distinct missions, one of war and one of reconstruction, the Marjah deployment will forever be more than just a military operation, or a battle, especially to those who were there.

It will never be a story just of success or failure. It will forever remain a part of who we are, as Marines who served there. And with time, and distance, our perspectives will continue to shift. You remember the emotions that cut through time. Loss, fear, things like that. The memories still exist, they seem so much cleaner. The battle for Marjah was not restricted to one period of time, or one unit — it was ongoing, and a great many American and allied forces were injured or killed trying to succeed at an incredible undertaking.

We grow and change. The battle of Marjah happened, but every year it goes by it gets a little bit different. He oversees daily editorial operations, edits articles, and supports reporters so they can continue to write the impactful stories that matter to our audience. In terms of writing, James provides a mix of pop culture commentary and in-depth analysis of issues facing the military and veterans community. Contact the author here. The Battle for Marjah captures the agonizing the Marines go through upon learning that some of their brother Marines accidentally killed a woman and several children.

There is palpable discomfort at the exchange, an unease at how to handle such a situation with empathy and humanity. These Marines are not bad people, in other words, even if they get excited during the adrenaline rush of combat. The ultimate message from The Battle for Marjah is that there are no easy answers to these fundamental questions of the conduct of the war.

Just as importantly: we are not well served by those who insist there are. The Battle for Marjah covers events that are about a year old. As recently as three months ago there were news stories of combat, IEDs, and misery, even as General David Petraeus insisted Marjah was a shining example of how the surge of 30, troops ordered by President Obama was winning the war. It remains to be seen how the area will wind up: the security gains are, indeed, remarkable, but as the closing moments of The Battle for Marjah note, the fabled "government-in-a-box" has not yet materialized.

There is no government, in other words, only an unstable local defense force, and the Afghan security forces are non-Pashtun Tajiks and Hazaras. It makes one wonder: are expectations too high?

Or are we getting something fundamentally wrong? We may not be able to answer those questions for a long time. He blogs about Central Asia at www. Shusha was the key to the recent war between Azerbaijan and Armenia. Now Baku wants to turn the fabled fortress town into a resort. By Joshua Foust, February 22, February 22, , PM.

November 11, , PM.